GerrymappingOpen the map

April 28, 2004

Vieth v. Jubelirer

No test for partisan gerrymandering, and no relief.

See it on the timeline

U.S. Reports
The first page of Vieth v. Jubelirer, 541 U.S. 267, as printed in the U.S. Reports. The Supreme Court decided the case on April 28, 2004.U.S. Reports · April 28, 2004 · Library of Congress, U.S. Reports · Original

Democrats challenge Pennsylvania's map as a partisan gerrymander. A four-justice plurality says such claims can't be judged. Justice Anthony Kennedy, the deciding vote, refuses to close the door entirely, which sets off fifteen years of searches for a workable standard.

See the 108th Congress map (2003–2005) →

Sources

← Texas redraws in the middle of the decadeThe first woman Speaker →

Explore