GerrymappingOpen the map

June 27, 2019

Rucho v. Common Cause

Federal courts are out of the partisan gerrymandering business.

See it on the timeline

Photo by Carol M. Highsmith
Inside the U.S. Supreme Court building in Washington.Photo by Carol M. Highsmith · 1980–2006 · Wikimedia Commons · Original

Ruling on a Republican map in North Carolina and a Democratic one in Maryland, the Court holds 5–4 that partisan gerrymandering claims are political questions federal courts cannot decide. Chief Justice John Roberts writes the majority.

Justice Elena Kagan's dissent warns that the practice threatens self-government.

Behind the lines

The fight moves to state courts, state constitutions, and ballot measures creating independent commissions. Michigan, Colorado, Virginia and others adopted new systems around this time.

With federal courts out, the only limits on a legislature's partisan map are those in its own state's law, which sets up the mid-decade fights of 2025.

See the 116th Congress map (2019–2021) →

Sources

On the state pages

← Pennsylvania's map struck downA pandemic Congress →

Explore